Tungsten vs Molybdenum
Both are transition metals, so they share the same broad chemistry.
The differences in plain English
- They sit in the same column, group 6, so they have the same number of outer electrons and react in similar ways; the heavier one, Tungsten, is usually the more reactive of the two if they are metals, and the less reactive if they are non-metals.
- Both are solids at room temperature.
- Tungsten is denser, about 87 per cent more than Molybdenum (19.25 against 10.28 g/cm³).
- Tungsten melts at 3422 °C, far above Molybdenum at 2623 °C.
- An atom of Tungsten is about 1.9 times heavier than an atom of Molybdenum (183.84 u against 95.95 u).
- Tungsten pulls electrons more strongly in a bond (electronegativity 2.36 against 2.16).
Side by side
| Tungsten | Molybdenum | |
|---|---|---|
| Atomic number | 74 | 42 |
| Symbol | W | Mo |
| Family | Transition metal | Transition metal |
| Group / period | 6 / 6 | 6 / 5 |
| State at room temperature | Solid | Solid |
| Atomic mass | 183.841 u | 95.951 u |
| Density | 19.25 g/cm³ | 10.28 g/cm³ |
| Melting point | 3422 °C | 2623 °C |
| Boiling point | 5930 °C | 4639 °C |
| Electronegativity | 2.36 | 2.16 |
| First ionisation energy | 770 kJ/mol | 684.3 kJ/mol |
| Electron configuration | [Xe] 4f14 5d4 6s2 | [Kr] 4d5 5s1 |
| Discovered by | Carl Wilhelm Scheele | Carl Wilhelm Scheele |
Tungsten
For most of the twentieth century, tungsten lit the world. A coil of tungsten wire heated to more than 2500 °C glows white, and because tungsten melts at a higher temperature than any other metal, it could do this for thousands of hours without failing. The incandescent bulb is fading now, but tungsten has not. Its hardness, heat resistance and sheer density keep it in cutting tools, armour, X-ray machines, welding rods and the tips of darts.
- Tungsten has the highest melting point of any metal, at about 3422 °C, which is why it served as the filament in light bulbs for a century.
- Tungsten is almost exactly as dense as gold, and gold plated tungsten bars have been used in attempts to counterfeit bullion.
Molybdenum
Nearly every living thing needs molybdenum, and it is the heaviest element with a role in the human body. Soil and ocean bacteria use a molybdenum enzyme to break the tough bond in nitrogen gas and make ammonia, the process on which most of the world's protein depends. Yet for most of history nobody knew molybdenum existed, because its main mineral looked exactly like lead ore or graphite.
- Molybdenum is the most abundant transition metal dissolved in the oceans, which is why marine microbes evolved to depend on it.
- The enzyme nitrogenase, which lets bacteria turn nitrogen gas into ammonia, has molybdenum at its heart, and most of the protein on Earth passes through it.
Colour the bubbles by density or melting point and the difference jumps out.
More comparisons
Data from Periodic-Table-JSON (CC BY-SA); temperatures rounded to the nearest degree. Written by Anthony.